In addition to helping with #COMMS - mostly beating back disinformation - about the #Helene response, and helping old and new clients push out statements about the Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (#LCRI), there was the release of American Water Works Association and Association of Metropolitan Water Agencies (AMWA)'s opening brief in their suit against the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)'s #PFAS MCLs.
It lays out what I think is a very strong case for throwing out them out, and that's before you consider the impacts of the reversal of the Chevron Doctrine, where - to use a baseball term - a tie went to the regulator. Now a tie goes to a judge.
This is NOT a defense of finding PFAS in our drinking #water; it's quite the opposite.
Because the EPA decided to use a mix of scientific, legal, and political reasoning - revealed through their #fuzzymath about the cost vs. health benefits estimates - they left themselves wide open for reversal.
And such a reversal will mean that all of these years evaluating PFAS for new MCLs have been wasted. Because the EPA arrogantly decided to run with 4 ppt and a first-ever Hazard Index instead of setting MCLs in line with the states that have been tackling PFAS.
Michigan. Wisconsin. Minnesota. New York. New Jersey. Pennsylvania. And more...
They did the work with their experts and academics to set MCLs that balanced public health and costs to the utilities and the consumers.
When it announced the MCLs, simply stated it would save X number of lives and prevent Y number of illnesses. It didn't provide proof for those numbers, and they certainly didn't lay out why the states they were superseding were wrong.
Now, #utilities can't plan for the MCLs to be tossed; I estimate 10,000 to 20,000 of them have to continue on the path toward advanced treatment to get them under 4 ppt and in line with the Hazard Index.
What a waste of time, effort, and money. When the answer to protective and responsible MCLs was right in front of the EPA for the taking.
And they ignored the answer.
Congratulations to the whole LEEP team! We look forward to following and amplifying your progress.