A TRANS RESEARCHER'S PURSUIT OF BETTER DATA ON DETRANSITION
Kinnon MacKinnon leads the world’s largest study on people who stop or reverse their gender transitions...
Kinnon MacKinnon, a Canadian researcher, was only faintly surprised this spring when the website for an upcoming conference did not list his talk alongside the dozens of others. He was slated to discuss one of the most fraught topics in medicine: patients who transition to a different gender but later change their minds, known as detransition.
The Pediatric Endocrine Society, which organized the conference, said that his presentation was kept under wraps because of safety concerns; there had been protests against gender medicine at the previous year’s gathering...
Dr. MacKinnon, a 39-year-old assistant professor of social work at York University in Toronto, is transgender, and he presented alongside another trans researcher. As he took the microphone, he joked: “They really get the trans people in to talk about the easy topics, eh?”
He’s gotten used to trying to defuse tension — at scientific meetings and gender clinics, and in TikTok posts — as detransition, a once-obscure topic, has vaulted into the U.S. presidential campaign and an upcoming Supreme Court case...
My Ph.D. project looked at how clinicians assess whether trans adults are ready for hormones and surgeries. Worry about regret was one of the main considerations that doctors would use to deny access, and I studied how trans people experienced these assessments as gatekeeping...
The study included more than 900 people in the United States and Canada who had detransitioned, two-thirds of whom had undergone medical transitions.
One group detransitioned due to more internally driven factors, such as worsening mental health through transition, or reconceptualizing their identity, or treatment dissatisfaction. This is also the group that has the highest regret. That one is 90 percent assigned female at birth.
Another group of people who detransitioned was more positive. They had a change in identity, but they were satisfied with their treatment, and stopped because they were happy with where they were at.
And then another group detransitioned because of a lack of support and discrimination. And we did find that about 6 percent of our sample reported detransition because of state legislation in the U.S...
Most of the people who are having these experiences are L.G.B.T.Q. You don’t have to look very far back in the history books to see that medical systems can help us... they can also cause us harm...
There’s a paper published from a Dutch sample of trans adults who transitioned as children, and 35 to 44 percent reported infertility regret...
I think we’re going through that phase right now with detransition. It’s extremely sensationalized and polarized. It’s not as much focused on, what is the humanity?
Credit: Azeen Ghorayshi, Medium.com
Source: https://lnkd.in/ghyQ8T5s
Great to see AstraZeneca championing diversity and gender equity in hematology!