Dealing with unqualified candidates from an external recruiter. Are you ready to confront the issue head-on?
When dealing with unqualified candidates from an external recruiter, it's important to maintain a professional relationship while setting clear expectations. Here's how you can handle it effectively:
What strategies have you found effective in managing recruiter relationships?
Dealing with unqualified candidates from an external recruiter. Are you ready to confront the issue head-on?
When dealing with unqualified candidates from an external recruiter, it's important to maintain a professional relationship while setting clear expectations. Here's how you can handle it effectively:
What strategies have you found effective in managing recruiter relationships?
-
Recently, an external recruiter sent me a candidate who wasn’t remotely qualified for the role. Their experience didn’t match the requirements, and it was clear the recruiter hadn’t vetted them properly. Instead of dismissing the candidate outright, I took the time to evaluate their potential and learn their story. While they weren’t a fit, I gave them constructive feedback and let the recruiter know where their screening process fell short. It’s frustrating when external partners miss the mark, but I see it as an opportunity to reinforce expectations. Clear communication and holding recruiters accountable are crucial to building a talent pipeline that works.
-
While providing feedback is essential to help recruiters improve, repeated issues call for decisive action. Ideally, you should get ready in advance. 1. Set Clear KPIs, at least for your own quality control. For example, at least X% of candidates should qualify for the next interview round. 2. If unqualified candidates persist, reconsider the collaboration. Focus on hiring success rather than managing recruiter errors. 3. Ensure your agreement with recruiter allows for quick termination without penalties if the recruiter fails to meet expectations. Feedback is important, but clear benchmarks and flexibility safeguard your hiring process.
-
Confronting the issue of unqualified candidates from an external recruiter can be tricky, but it's crucial to address it directly in order to improve the quality of your hiring process. The key is to balance firmness with professionalism so that both you and the recruiter are on the same page moving forward. Double-check that your job requirements and expectations were clearly communicated to the recruiter in the first place. Acknowledge the effort the recruiter has put in, but be clear about the disconnect you're seeing between the candidates and the job requirements.Ultimately, the goal is not to burn bridges but to ensure that you can work together effectively. Give constructive feedback and frame the conversation.
-
Provide Clear/Specific Feedback: Outline the gaps in qualifications or mismatches with role requirements in a professional manner. Share examples of where the candidates fell short, ensuring the recruiter understands the expectations for future submissions. Firm but Fair Expectations: Reiterate the criteria for the role and the importance of aligning candidates with these standards. Offer resources or examples of ideal profiles to help the recruiter improve their candidate selection process and maintain accountability. Consequences and Next Steps: Address the impact of repeated mismatches on timelines and productivity, emphasizing the need for better alignment. Propose solutions, such as scheduled check-ins or revised sourcing strategies.
-
I don't look at it as an issue. In fact, best put, it is a feedback to the external recruiter on what they could improve/ change while screening the profiles for the role. Same applies to the internal recruiter when they get inputs/ feedback from the hiring managers.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Global Talent AcquisitionHow can you prepare for questions about sourcing and recruiting candidates?
-
SourcingHow do you handle feedback from hiring managers when presenting candidates?
-
RecruitingWhat are the most important things to do in your first month as a recruiter?
-
Full-life Cycle RecruitingHow do you adapt your full-life cycle recruiting approach to different roles and levels of seniority?