Quais os benefícios e desvantagens de utilizar estoque de segurança na gestão de estoques?

This is a basic question. It is taught to the students of purchase management, or inventory management in the first chapter of their studies. There is a risk of disruption of the operations if the safety stock is not maintained. On the contrary, miscalculation of the safety stock or excess safety stock increases the inventory carrying cost. Therefore, we need to strike a balance. But then achieving this balance is not easy. Safety stock depends on the location of the supplier, lead time required to get the material, reliability of the supplier, quality compliance by the supplier, etc.

Provides the required safety quantity based on the desired service level. Allows different options and thus has a flexibility. User does have variability into account and thus has the ability to make decisions based on different parameters.

Prevents Stockouts Safety stock acts as a buffer against unexpected demand spikes or supply chain disruptions, ensuring product availability. Enhances Customer Satisfaction By maintaining safety stock, businesses can meet customer demand promptly, leading to higher customer satisfaction and loyalty. Smooths Operations It helps maintain a continuous production and sales process, avoiding delays caused by inventory shortages. Protects Against Forecast Errors Safety stock mitigates risks associated with inaccuracies in demand forecasting by providing a cushion. Supports Lead Time Variability It accounts for fluctuations in supplier lead times, reducing the impact of delays in replenishment.

No considero un beneficio mantener un stock de seguridad, puesto que puede ocultar problemas latentes como variaciones en la demanda, problemas de calidad, retrasos en la entrega de proveedores, fallas en la planificación, entre otros. Es fundamental gestionar los inventarios de una manera más dinámica. La metodología DDMRP, con su enfoque en buffers de stock para regular los niveles de inventario, me parece mucho más eficiente desde cualquier perspectiva. Esta metodología no solo mejora la visibilidad y la respuesta ante las fluctuaciones del mercado, sino que también optimiza el uso de recursos y reduce el capital inmovilizado.

O principal benefício de manter um estoque de segurança, é garantir a continuidade do nível de serviço, permitindo que seu produto esteja sempre disponível para o cliente, sem riscos de excessos ou rupturas. Dessa forma, você dimensiona seu estoque de maneira eficiente, equilibrando a disponibilidade com a otimização dos recursos.

It is theoretical. Cannot work on a large scale with statistically obtained demand numbers. Can thus work only based on consumption/historic sales data. Requires forecast to be deployed. Doesnt cover for the lead time demand.

Increased Holding Costs Maintaining safety stock increases storage and handling costs, impacting overall inventory carrying costs. Capital Tied Up Safety stock requires investment, which ties up capital that could be used elsewhere in the business. Risk of Obsolescence Holding extra inventory increases the risk of products becoming obsolete, especially in fast-moving industries. Complex Inventory Management Managing safety stock adds complexity to inventory management processes and requires careful planning. Potential for Overstocking Excessive safety stock can lead to overstocking, resulting in higher costs and reduced efficiency.

Uno de los inconvenientes que observo en el manejo del stock de seguridad es la frecuencia de revisión de los niveles de inventario. En muchas empresas, este stock se actualiza una vez al año, y en las más diligentes, cuatro veces al año (una por trimestre). Sin embargo, dada la naturaleza fluctuante de la demanda y los largos tiempos de entrega de los proveedores (por ejemplo, desde China), un ajuste no realizado a tiempo puede resultar en un exceso de inventario. Esto se traduce en capital inmovilizado, uso ineficiente de la capacidad de almacenamiento y un flujo de caja invertido sin propósito, afectando negativamente la eficiencia operativa y financiera de la empresa.

Determine Demand Variability Calculate the standard deviation of demand during the lead time period to understand demand variability. Assess Lead Time Variability Measure the standard deviation of lead times to account for supply chain fluctuations. Use Service Level Decide on the desired service level (e.g., 95%) to determine the acceptable risk of stockouts. Apply the Safety Stock Formula Use the formula: Safety Stock = Z-score × Standard Deviation of Demand During Lead Time. The Z-score corresponds to the desired service level. Review Regularly Periodically reassess demand and lead time variability to ensure the safety stock level remains optimal.

Formula is standard and ideally can be applied to cover for both demand and lead time variations. Safety stock = (Z-score x standard deviation of demand x lead time) - (average demand x lead time) The Z-score is a statistical measure that indicates how many standard deviations away from the mean you want to set your safety stock level. It reflects your desired service level or the probability of not having a stockout. For example, a Z-score of 1.65 corresponds to a 95% service level, while a Z-score of 2.33 corresponds to a 99% service level.

EOQ-based inventory optimisation is theoretical. Its utility is restricted to academic studies only. Hardly any practising manager calculates the EOQ. EOQ depends on the calculation of the inventory carrying cost and ordering cost. It requires immense expertise to calculate accurately these two costs. In point 3 mentioned above, a formula to calculate the Z-score and safety stock is given. It can be further used to calculate safety stock.

1. Foundation for Safety Stock: The cornerstone of optimal safety stock lies in accurate demand forecasting. Historical sales data, seasonal trends, and any marketing initiatives should be factored into your forecasts. 2. Safety Lead Time: Consider the lead time required to receive new inventory after placing an order. A longer lead time necessitates a higher safety stock buffer to account for potential delays. 3. Target Service Level: Determine your desired service level, which refers to the percentage of customer demands you aim to fulfill without a stockout. A higher service level necessitates more safety stock.

Get the segmentation (ABC/XYZ) analysis done first. do not calculate/plan for inventories based on the full lead time. Continuous review is needed. There should be a closed loop feedback system from Inventory planing back to demand planning.

Zoning tool, Availability and Reliability reports. Days of coverage/Days of inventory - all of this can help to measure the performance.

The first goal is to measure the Safety Stock Level. For companies with over 10,000 items, I recommend categorizing safety stock by tier levels based on profit. Next, monitor the transaction history and mark each instance where you reached your safety stock, depleted it, and recovered from it. This approach allows you to identify the events that caused you to fall into the safety stock zone and understand the duration required to recover from it and hopefully adapt to it.

this is an iterative process. There is no such thing as the right safety level. we can only get to the closest level and ofcourse the performance measurement can tell how well the numbers have performed. For continuous improvements, lots of measures have to be studied, order horizon pattern from the customers, inventory strategy towards based on how close we want to be towards the market delivery. Like I have written before, this should be a closed loop system for this to work correctly.

En la mayoría de los sistemas de planificación, el stock de seguridad se considera un valor fijo diseñado para cubrir, en gran medida, las desviaciones del pronóstico. Sin embargo, dado que la demanda es dinámica y los tiempos de revisión y actualización del stock de seguridad no son muy frecuentes, esta práctica puede resultar poco efectiva. El modelo DDMRP (Demand Driven Material Requirements Planning), al gestionar buffers de stock, permite actualizaciones diarias de los niveles de inventario. Esto no solo mantiene un flujo constante de materiales sino que también asegura un nivel de servicio óptimo, adaptándose de manera más ágil a las fluctuaciones del mercado y mejorando la eficiencia operativa.