You're evaluating a startup's financial projections. Are they too good to be true during due diligence?
When evaluating a startup’s financial projections, it's crucial to discern realistic forecasts from overly optimistic ones. Here are some strategies to help you navigate this process:
Have any thoughts on evaluating startup projections? Share your insights.
You're evaluating a startup's financial projections. Are they too good to be true during due diligence?
When evaluating a startup’s financial projections, it's crucial to discern realistic forecasts from overly optimistic ones. Here are some strategies to help you navigate this process:
Have any thoughts on evaluating startup projections? Share your insights.
-
Startups almost never met financial projections. In a study we did time ago analyzing our portfolio companies, come out that the majority are too optimistic. That is OK. Entrepreneurs should be optimistic. But, as an investor you should know that and almost cut by two the projected data.
-
Startups' financial projections can tell you a lot more about the team / product / tech / market than the numbers. I suggest thinking about what the numbers are trying to tell you. E.g. Do the founders know the market well enough? Do they have enough confidence / ambitions? Do they know the 'huddle' rate to be venture-backable? Do they know what they are saying about their plans? Like in most things in life, it's not what it seems on the surface!
-
Simple hacks: 1. Establish what’s ‘normal’ based on the context of the start up, toughest three current or potential competitors and examine its delta from the ‘abnormal’ projections. 2. Ask if that delta is explained by the MOAT and differentiation claimed by the start up. 3. Check for the traction that proves the delta. 4. Examine the unit economics and whether it aligns with the claimed capabilities and asset productivity, by the start up. 5. Establish the range of XIRRs assuming downside with the worst case coming true see if the fund economics allows one to invest. 6. Do not invest, even if the above is addressed, if pressured due to time trap.
-
Startup financial projections are not meant to be accurate. However, they can be helpful in illustrating three things 1. If all goes well (as projected), what is the potential? Early stage VCs focus on businesses that can be a home run. The financial projects illustrate if the venture has the potential to deliver those outsized returns 2. Startup projections also help understand the unit economics of a business. What is target price? How does that compare to cost of goods/services sold? And what does it take to acquire customers? 3. The forecast will also demonstrate how experienced and financially aware a founder is. Many founders are first-time entrepreneurs or are not financially savvy. So an investor may not hold it against them.
-
Vision of Growth: They show the scale of what’s possible if all goes according to plan. Investors need to see the potential for substantial returns to back your idea. Business Mechanics: Projections shed light on the unit economics—pricing, costs, and customer acquisition. They’re the blueprint for how the business can sustain itself. Founder’s Preparedness: These numbers reflect the founder’s financial awareness and strategic thinking. Even for first-timers, a solid effort speaks volumes about their readiness to navigate challenges.
-
While there are of course some aspects of a venture company's financial projections that are worthy of evaluation, such as the cutting-edge technology, a novel business model, and a young and vibrant organization, there are also many unstable factors such as industry sectors, the competitive environment, and customer trends. Therefore, it is realistic to consider how to discount financial forecasts for venture companies. Discounting factors include the following ones: 1) Benchmarking the financials of competitors 2) Probability of maintaining technology patents and specificity 3) Viability in comparison to industry sectors and legacy industries. 4)Hostile takeover risk and legal risk 5) Risk of management and executive departures.
-
When assessing a startup's financial projections, it’s vital to evaluate their feasibility with a critical eye. Start by examining whether the growth rates and revenue targets are grounded in realistic expectations for the sector. Pay close attention to the foundational assumptions, including the estimated market potential and expense forecasts like customer acquisition costs. Analyze any available historical financial data to identify patterns or gaps that might challenge the validity of future predictions. By adopting a methodical approach and questioning the rationale behind each figure, you can differentiate between well-substantiated projections and overly ambitious estimations.
-
Key methods investors use to evaluate a startup's financial forecasts for investment: - Financial Projections - Burn Rate - Break-even Analysis - Market Potential - Customer Acquisition Costs (CAC) - Competitive Analysis - Scenario Analysis - Revenue Streams For early stage follow cut by 2, but allow the entrepreneurs to prove their creativity over years.
-
I start with the CRM ( marketing and sales pipeline ) and make a direct link to budgeted revenue. I do believe in 50 - 100 % growth, but the faster you grow the more working capital you need. Mostly that is financed by equity, and too often a follow-on financing round is not included in the financial plan. One of my SaaS companies grew in 10 years from 0 to 4 M in revenues and during the next 10 years from 4 to 100 M in revenues - with 4 financing rounds of 100 M. When doing a financial plan for Series A you could also show the impact of a much larger Series B 18 - 24 months down the road.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Venture CapitalHow can you help your portfolio companies navigate going public?
-
Corporate FinanceYou're analyzing a startup with limited financial history. How can you determine its financial health?
-
Venture CapitalYour company's valuation is being questioned by an investor. How do you handle the scrutiny?
-
Small BusinessHow can you show traction and market validation to investors?