Your direct report is defensive during evaluations. How can you provide feedback effectively?
When your direct report becomes defensive during evaluations, it's essential to approach the situation with empathy and clarity. Here’s how you can provide effective feedback:
What strategies have you found effective for providing feedback?
Your direct report is defensive during evaluations. How can you provide feedback effectively?
When your direct report becomes defensive during evaluations, it's essential to approach the situation with empathy and clarity. Here’s how you can provide effective feedback:
What strategies have you found effective for providing feedback?
-
Here's my true & tried recipe: Always begin by creating a safe and respectful environment. Start the evaluation with positive feedback, highlighting contributions. When you get to the negative feedback, focus on how behaviors or outcomes (not traits) can be improved. This frames the discussion as a partnership aimed at mutual improvement. Listen actively and avoid invalidating their feelings, even if you disagree with their viewpoint, showing empathy to defuse defensiveness. However, be clear and direct about your feedback. Lastly, try to set actionable goals and emphasize future growth rather than dwelling on past mistakes. End the conversation by reaffirming your belief in their abilities and expressing optimism about their growth.
-
In my opinion, The Constructive and Effective Feedback has five pillars: 1. Identifying the Opportunity: Recognize moments that generate feedback needs, providing clear facts and perspectives. 2. Healthy Environment: Ensure a constructive, emotionally safe environment for effective communication. 3. Positive Intention: Approach feedback with a positive mindset, avoiding preconceived judgments. 4. Looking to the Future: Develop a clear action plan for future improvements through training, coaching, or mentoring. 5. Emotional Anchoring: Make feedback memorable by choosing unique locations, using metaphors, and creating symbols that reinforce the connection.
-
To provide feedback effectively to a defensive direct report, approach the evaluation with empathy and a focus on growth. Begin by creating a safe and supportive environment, emphasizing your intention to help them improve. Use specific examples of their performance, balancing constructive criticism with positive reinforcement to highlight their strengths. Frame feedback in terms of development opportunities rather than failures, encouraging a growth mindset. Ask open-ended questions to engage them in the conversation and understand their perspective. Finally, collaboratively set actionable goals for improvement, ensuring they feel supported and motivated to make positive changes moving forward.
-
Understanding The Root Causes Of Defensiveness Understanding the root causes of defensiveness during evaluations is crucial for providing effective feedback to direct reports. Defensiveness often stems from a variety of underlying emotional and psychological factors. One primary cause is the fear of criticism or failure. Employees may perceive feedback as an attack on their competence, prompting them to react defensively to protect their self-esteem. This fear might be exacerbated if they have had negative experiences with feedback in the past or if they associate their self-worth with their job performance. Another contributing factor is a lack of trust or rapport between the evaluator and the direct report.
-
The most important thing is the kind of credibility we as leaders develop with the team so that the team trusts us and feel safe when we give them feedback. Self realisation is one of the effective tools, which can be used to give constructive feedback the employee. A set of open ended questions can be sent in advance or during the discussion itself, which slowly handholds the employee, and steers them in the direction where they realise their areas of improvement. With this approach, the defensiveness can reduce, you can enter into an open dialogue and jointly arrive at an action plan including what you as a leader can do to offer help and improve their capability.
-
1. Ensure that the feedback session takes place in a private and comfortable setting. 2. Start the conversation with positive feedback and acknowledge their strengths and contributions. 3. Focus on specific behaviors and examples rather than generalizations. Use objective language and avoid personal attacks. 4. Give them an opportunity to share their perspective and listen without interrupting. 5. Frame the feedback in a way that emphasizes growth and improvement. Discuss solutions and action plans to address the issues. 6. Use "I" statements to express your observations and feelings. For example, "I feel concerned when deadlines are missed because it affects the team's progress." This approach is less accusatory and more collaborative.
-
Always remember that performance evaluations are meant to be evaluative …& developmental. Performance feedback is the “breakfast of champions”. Be sure to include praise for what is going well, an offer of support with resources, as well as what needs improvement. When all are rated “superior”, it hurts the really high performers. Be sure to link rewards, bonuses, & other benefits with performance that is both objectively & subjectively measured. This process is critical & predictive of high performing organizations.
-
This requires a thoughtful and empathetic approach. Here’s how you can make the conversation productive: 1. Be Empathetic: -Acknowledge their feelings and emphasise that the feedback is intended to support their growth, not to criticize them. 2. Reframe the Feedback as Developmental: -Position the feedback as an opportunity for improvement and learning: “This is an area where I think you have great potential to grow.” -Discuss actionable steps they can take to address the feedback, focusing on solutions rather than problems. 3. Follow Up and Offer Support: -End the conversation by summarizing agreed-upon actions and expressing confidence in their ability to improve. Schedule a follow-up meeting to check progress and provide ongoing guidance
-
Approach the feedback conversation with empathy and clarity. Start by acknowledging their strengths to build trust. Use specific examples and focus on behaviors, not personal traits. Frame feedback as an opportunity for growth and improvement, not criticism. Ask open-ended questions to encourage self-reflection and collaboration on solutions. Keep the tone positive and forward-focused, and offer support to help them improve.
-
When giving feedback to a defensive direct report, it is important to create an environment that minimises defensiveness and encourages openness. 1. Prepare for the conversation: Identify specific examples, focus on facts than opinions. 2. Clarify the purpose: Mention the evaluation is an opportunity for growth and not criticism. 3. Start with strengths acknowledging their contributions and achievements 4. Instead of general feedback, provide concrete examples and suggest ways to improve 5. Invite their perspective on the feedback 6. End on a positive note with focus on the future: Let them know you are committed to their success!
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Staffing ServicesHow can you ensure your feedback is well-received?
-
Presentation SkillsWhat do you do if you receive conflicting feedback from multiple sources during a presentation?
-
CommunicationWhat's the best way to handle negative feedback in emails and memos?
-
Market ResearchHere's how you can effectively handle constructive criticism from supervisors in Market Research.