You're dealing with a defensive team member. How can you effectively provide feedback?
Dealing with a defensive colleague can be challenging, especially when you need to provide feedback. Here's how to approach the situation:
- Approach with empathy, acknowledging their feelings before diving into feedback.
- Be specific and objective, focusing on behaviors and outcomes rather than personal traits.
- Encourage a two-way dialogue, allowing them space to share their perspective and concerns.
How do you handle providing feedback to someone who may not take it well? Share your strategies.
You're dealing with a defensive team member. How can you effectively provide feedback?
Dealing with a defensive colleague can be challenging, especially when you need to provide feedback. Here's how to approach the situation:
- Approach with empathy, acknowledging their feelings before diving into feedback.
- Be specific and objective, focusing on behaviors and outcomes rather than personal traits.
- Encourage a two-way dialogue, allowing them space to share their perspective and concerns.
How do you handle providing feedback to someone who may not take it well? Share your strategies.
-
To provide feedback to a defensive team member, start by creating a safe and non-judgmental environment. Use "I" statements instead of "You" to avoid sounding accusatory, e.g., “I noticed…” rather than “You always…”. Focus on specific behaviors, not personality traits, and highlight the impact of their actions on the team or outcomes. Balance your feedback with positive reinforcement, recognizing their strengths to build trust. Invite their perspective with open-ended questions like, “What’s your view on this?”. Stay calm, patient, and solution-focused, emphasizing collaboration, e.g., “How can we work on this together?”. This approach minimizes defensiveness and promotes growth.
-
Como engenheiro de manutenção de via permanente e Lean Six Sigma Green Belt, você combina habilidades técnicas e de liderança para promover melhorias contínuas. Ao lidar com um membro defensivo, é essencial usar ferramentas como o DMAIC e focar em feedback construtivo. Construa confiança com comunicação aberta, empatia e reconhecimento. Baseie-se em dados para definir, medir, analisar e melhorar. Seja específico, focando em comportamentos, não em pessoas, e ofereça soluções claras. Defina metas, prazos e acompanhe o progresso, adaptando sua abordagem e criando um ambiente seguro. Assim, promove-se o crescimento individual e o fortalecimento da equipe. #LeanSixSigma #GestãoDeEquipes #DMAIC #TrabalhoEmEquipe #GestãoDePessoas
-
When trying to get past an employee’s defensiveness, begin the conversation with affirmative feedback. Do not personalise the incident; concentrate on the act and describe it. For example, rather than telling a subordinate: ‘You are not proactive,’ ask questions such as: ‘I saw that some deadlines were not met; how do we work towards ensuring that doesn’t happen again?’ Seek first to understand their position and then look for ways both of you might address the issue together. I tried this approach with another person: By presenting the feedback as a discussion of a show, we managed to defuse tension and find results-oriented solutions together.
-
When providing feedback to a defensive team member, start by creating a supportive environment. Choose a private setting where they feel safe to express their thoughts. Begin the conversation with positive reinforcement by acknowledging their strengths and contributions. This helps to build rapport and reduces defensiveness. Next, focus on specific behaviors rather than personal attributes. Use "I" statements to express how their actions impact the team or project, such as, “I noticed that deadlines were missed, which affected our progress.” Encourage open dialogue by asking for their perspective and listening actively. This shows that you value their input and fosters a collaborative atmosphere.
-
Focus on Behaviors, Not Personality: Highlight specific actions and their impact, avoiding personal judgments. Invite Dialogue: Ask for their perspective and make it a two-way conversation to reduce defensiveness.
-
When providing feedback to a defensive team member, focus on a constructive and empathetic approach. Use “I” statements to avoid sounding accusatory, highlight specific behaviors rather than personal traits, and balance criticism with positive reinforcement. Encourage dialogue by asking for their perspective and offer solutions for improvement collaboratively.
-
Feedback is very important as one of the basis for improvement. Be objective. When you are wrong, accept and correct it. It might be simple to others but also hard to others. Have an open discussion with the member and approach it with empathy. Acknowledge and understand that person. Discuss to him the current status of the project, what went well and what went wrong. That one important thing to do is to regularly provide feedback to your team so all of you can have the full picture of the situation. Involve that person in the discussion and solicit ideas from him. He will develop his trust and sense of belongingness after some time. Continue to find ways to develop bonding and sense of inclusion to that person.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
NegotiationHere's how you can effectively give feedback to someone who is highly sensitive or easily offended.
-
Team FacilitationWhat do you do if feedback triggers defensiveness or personal offense?
-
TrainingHere's how you can offer helpful feedback to your boss while avoiding offense.
-
Constructive FeedbackHow do you use feedback frequency and timing to motivate and empower others?