Last updated on Aug 10, 2024

How would you handle feedback sessions when team members have opposing views on performance?

Handling feedback sessions effectively is a critical component of fostering a healthy team environment, especially when team members have conflicting opinions on performance. It's a delicate balance to maintain open communication while ensuring that everyone feels heard and respected. Your role in navigating these discussions is pivotal in promoting teamwork and achieving a constructive outcome. The key lies in preparation, active listening, and a structured approach that acknowledges diverse perspectives while guiding the team towards consensus and improvement.

Find expert answers in this collaborative article

Selected by the community from 9 contributions. Learn more

1 Prepare Thoroughly

Before entering a feedback session where opposing views are expected, thorough preparation is essential. You should gather all relevant performance data and feedback to present an objective foundation for the discussion. This includes project outcomes, individual contributions, and any prior evaluations that are pertinent to the conversation. By starting with facts, you can create a neutral ground for everyone to discuss their views. It's also important to set clear objectives for the session, ensuring that the focus remains on constructive outcomes rather than personal disagreements.

Add your perspective

Ulises Tejeda
Report contribution
Crear un Entorno Seguro y Respetuoso: Establece desde el principio que la retroalimentación debe darse y recibirse en un entorno de respeto mutuo. Fomenta la confianza y asegura que todos los miembros del equipo se sientan cómodos compartiendo sus opiniones.

Translated

Like
Lawrence Alala

Revenue & Reservations Management | Front Office Operations | Sales & Marketing
Report contribution
Set Clear Objectives: Begin the session by outlining the goals. Make it clear that the purpose is to improve team performance and individual growth, not to assign blame.

Like

2 Establish Ground Rules

To ensure a constructive feedback session, establish ground rules that promote respect and open dialogue. Encourage team members to listen actively and speak without interrupting. Remind everyone that the goal is to understand different perspectives, not to win an argument. It's also helpful to agree on a signal or phrase that anyone can use if the conversation becomes too heated, allowing for a moment of pause and reflection. These guidelines help create a safe space for all participants to share their thoughts openly.

Add your perspective

Ulises Tejeda
Report contribution
Durante la retroalimentación, es importante diferenciar entre hechos y opiniones. Facilita la discusión enfocándote en datos objetivos y comportamientos observables, y aclara cualquier malentendido que pueda surgir.

Translated

Like
Lawrence Alala

Revenue & Reservations Management | Front Office Operations | Sales & Marketing
Report contribution
Create a Safe Environment: Ensure that everyone feels comfortable expressing their views. Emphasize respect and active listening. You might say, “Let’s make sure everyone has a chance to speak and be heard.”

Like

3 Facilitate Fairly

As the facilitator, your role is to guide the conversation and ensure that each team member has an opportunity to voice their opinions. Listen actively and acknowledge the feelings and perspectives being shared, even if they are contradictory. Ask open-ended questions to delve deeper into the reasons behind each viewpoint. Your impartiality is crucial; remain neutral and focused on helping the team work through their differences to find common ground or agreeable solutions.

Add your perspective

Ulises Tejeda
Report contribution
Fomentar el Diálogo Constructivo: Enfoca la discusión en encontrar soluciones en lugar de señalar culpables. Pregunta a los miembros del equipo cómo creen que se pueden mejorar las situaciones en disputa y cómo se pueden implementar esos cambios.

Translated

Like
Lawrence Alala

Revenue & Reservations Management | Front Office Operations | Sales & Marketing
Report contribution
Use Structured Feedback Models: Techniques like the Start, Stop, and Continue model can help structure the feedback. Each person states something they would like others to start doing, stop doing, and continue doing1. This keeps feedback constructive and focused on behaviors rather than personal attributes.

Like

4 Encourage Empathy

Encouraging empathy among team members can bridge gaps in understanding and soften resistance to opposing views. Prompt team members to consider their colleagues' perspectives by asking how they might feel or react in a similar situation. Highlighting shared goals and values can also remind everyone of the bigger picture and the collective effort required to achieve success. When team members empathize with one another, they are more likely to collaborate effectively and find mutually beneficial solutions.

Add your perspective

Lawrence Alala

Revenue & Reservations Management | Front Office Operations | Sales & Marketing
Report contribution
Encourage Empathy: Ask team members to try to understand each other’s perspectives. This can be facilitated by asking questions like, “Can you explain why you feel this way?” or “How do you think this impacts the team?”

Like

5 Seek Consensus

Seeking consensus does not mean that everyone will agree on every point, but rather that the team reaches a collective agreement on how to move forward. Encourage team members to identify areas of agreement and build on those. If disagreements persist, explore alternative solutions or compromises that address the concerns of all parties involved. The aim is to end the session with actionable steps that reflect the team's collaborative input and commitment.

Add your perspective

Lawrence Alala

Revenue & Reservations Management | Front Office Operations | Sales & Marketing
Report contribution
Facilitate a Balanced Discussion: Ensure that all voices are heard. If one person is dominating the conversation, gently steer it back to others by saying, “I’d like to hear from everyone on this.”

Like

6 Follow Up

After the feedback session, it's important to follow up with clear action items and support. Document the decisions made and the next steps agreed upon, and share this summary with the team to ensure accountability. Schedule check-ins to review progress and address any ongoing concerns. Consistent follow-up demonstrates your commitment to the team's development and reinforces the value of collaborative problem-solving.

Add your perspective

Neha Sharma

Accountant |
Report contribution
Feedback is one of the stage of planning and task. When we get feedback be assured properly documented it. Then consult with seniors about the feedback, and get follow up about the feedback. If we get negative feedback then try to resolve that particular issue, when we get positive feedback then try to find out what was the key Points about the success which can be use in next project. Follow up

Like

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

How would you handle feedback sessions when team members have opposing views on performance?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Prepare Thoroughly

2 Establish Ground Rules

3 Facilitate Fairly

4 Encourage Empathy

5 Seek Consensus

6 Follow Up

7 Here’s what else to consider

Teamwork

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Teamwork

More relevant reading

How would you handle feedback sessions when team members have opposing views on performance?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Prepare Thoroughly

2 Establish Ground Rules

3 Facilitate Fairly

4 Encourage Empathy

5 Seek Consensus

6 Follow Up

7 Here’s what else to consider

Teamwork

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

Explore Other Skills