Your team member is monopolizing the brainstorming session. How can you ensure everyone's voice is heard?
When one team member dominates the brainstorming, it's essential to level the playing field for idea sharing. To ensure everyone's voice is heard:
- Set clear ground rules at the start that limit speaking time and encourage round-robin sharing.
- Use a "talking stick" method where only the person holding an object may speak, ensuring equal opportunity.
- Implement anonymous idea submission through writing, allowing quieter members to contribute without pressure.
How do you handle overbearing voices in group discussions? What strategies work for your team?
Your team member is monopolizing the brainstorming session. How can you ensure everyone's voice is heard?
When one team member dominates the brainstorming, it's essential to level the playing field for idea sharing. To ensure everyone's voice is heard:
- Set clear ground rules at the start that limit speaking time and encourage round-robin sharing.
- Use a "talking stick" method where only the person holding an object may speak, ensuring equal opportunity.
- Implement anonymous idea submission through writing, allowing quieter members to contribute without pressure.
How do you handle overbearing voices in group discussions? What strategies work for your team?
-
This is a timeless classic. It must be prevented and avoided BEFORE the session takes place, by speaking honestly with the monopolizer: "Hey, you always give the key ideas and I really appreciate it because without you things wouldn't go so well, but how about letting someone else give the first idea? Just for a change. Afterwards you contribute with yours, which are the ones that make the difference and deliver value." And during the session, by encouraging directly the participants who don't like to contribute. Something like: "I would like to know what XXXXX thinks about this, because in his/her position as YYYY he/she has a lot of knowledge on the subject and we should not miss this." Easy but difficult:-)
-
When someone dominates a brainstorming session, it’s important to gently redirect the flow to make space for others. Start by setting ground rules upfront, like limiting speaking time or encouraging round-robin sharing. You can also introduce tools like sticky notes, shared docs, or platforms like Miro for anonymous idea submissions, so everyone has a chance to contribute equally. If needed, step in diplomatically—acknowledge the person’s input, then invite others by saying, “Let’s hear from someone who hasn’t had a chance yet.” Balancing voices helps tap into the full creativity of the group.
-
When one team member dominates the brainstorming session, it’s important to step in and create space for everyone to contribute. Set the tone early by encouraging everyone to share their ideas and establishing ground rules for equal participation. Gently redirect the dominant voice by saying, 'Let’s hear from others' or 'I’d love to get input from someone who hasn’t spoken yet.' You can also use structured methods like round-robin or anonymous idea collection to make sure all voices are heard. The goal is to create an inclusive environment where every idea has the chance to shine.
-
Do a roundtable and make sure everybody says something on the topic at hand. Some may not have anything to say and could voice it; however, it’s important for each member of the team to be asked his/her opinion, so that they feel included in the conversation.
-
Set ground rules for equitable participation. Use a ‘round-robin’ approach where each member shares ideas in turns. Encourage active listening and anonymous idea submissions if needed. As a leader, tactfully intervene to redirect focus, fostering an inclusive environment that sparks innovation
-
Brainstorming is a bad word. The loudest voice and/or highest person in the org chart will almost always win. The BEST way to solve this is to ELIMINATE the brainstorming session altogether. Rather, learn different ideation tools. I attended a course years ago that used this book: "The Innovator's Toolkit: 50+ Techniques for Predictable and Sustainable Organic Growth" 2nd Edition - and can be found on Amazon. It was a game changer and a life changer. It leveled the playing field for the participants. Everyone's ideas, adaptive or innovative, were heard and respected. Connecting dots becomes easier, ergo better vetted and implemented. Everyone has ideas - let them be heard! Message me for more information.
-
It is important to set up some rules before starting this process, you can start saying that you are going to hear at least an idea before someone who has already participated says another one.
-
first and foremost is set the ground rules explain to the participants that we are learning through sharing of knowledge and we learn better if we also listen to others viewpoints We are also checking on certain soft skills to be successful in todays work environment through this brainstorming so appreciate if we allow each member to contribute we need to act as a facilitator appreciating the dominant members point and immediately passing it to the next member make that person a facilitator and ask him to conduct the session
-
Ask him (it’s bound to be a him) to let others speak. After the meeting a) have a quiet word with him about the importance of listening, as well as talking; and b) have a quiet word with yourself for letting this happen in the first place.
-
Inicialmente agradecería todo su apoyo y esfuerzo, valorando su liderazgo, adicionalmente le hago saber que un trabajo equipo es enriquecedor y fomenta la.participacion, por lo tanto establecería reglas de participación que permita que todos los miembros se expresen libremente, en un determinado tiempo, respetando el derecho de palabra, opinión y tiempo de cada quien. Anotaría todas las ideas y al final realizaría un votación para elegir las propuestas más idóneas. Evidenciando así la participación y elección voluntaria por mayoría. Nadie manopoliza la toma de ediciones.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Large Group FacilitationWhat techniques can you use to keep large group sessions on track?
-
Large Group FacilitationHow can you make large group discussions productive?
-
ManagementHow can you keep group discussions on topic?
-
Personal DevelopmentHere's how you can articulate your ideas in team meetings and group discussions.