Your feedback makes a team member defensive. How can you communicate more effectively?
When your feedback makes a team member defensive, it's crucial to adjust your approach to foster a more open and constructive dialogue. Here's how you can improve your feedback delivery:
What strategies have you found effective in delivering feedback?
Your feedback makes a team member defensive. How can you communicate more effectively?
When your feedback makes a team member defensive, it's crucial to adjust your approach to foster a more open and constructive dialogue. Here's how you can improve your feedback delivery:
What strategies have you found effective in delivering feedback?
-
To avoid making a team member defensive, focus on a positive, solution-oriented approach. Start by acknowledging their efforts and contributions before addressing the issue. Use “I” statements, like “I noticed…” or “I feel…” instead of “You did…” This reduces the feeling of blame. Be specific and clear about the behavior or situation, rather than generalizing. Frame feedback as a collaborative opportunity for growth: “Let’s work together to improve…” Ensure the conversation is two-way, inviting their perspective and fostering an open dialogue. Lastly, maintain a calm and respectful tone, showing empathy and understanding. This helps build trust and reduces defensiveness.
-
To effectively communicate with a defensive team member, focus on the behavior, not the person. Use "I" statements to express how their behavior impacts you or the team, rather than blaming or accusing them. For instance, instead of saying, "You're always negative," say, "I feel discouraged when I hear negative comments." Additionally, actively listen to their perspective, validate their feelings, and seek common ground. By approaching the conversation with empathy and understanding, you can foster a more constructive dialogue and resolve the issue.
-
1. Focus on Behavior, Not Personality: Describe specific actions, not personal traits. Use "I" statements to avoid blame. Example: "When the report was late, it impacted the team's timeline." 2. Offer Solutions: Provide suggestions for improvement. Encourage collaboration. Example: "Perhaps we could use a project management tool to track deadlines." 3. Positive Reinforcement: Acknowledge their strengths. Express appreciation for their efforts. Example: "You're a great team player, and your dedication is valuable." 4. Choose the Right Time and Place: Have a private, one-on-one conversation. Avoid public criticism. Create a supportive environment.
-
I utilize the 'F.A.C.E.' framework to deliver feedback that fosters growth rather than defensiveness: Focus on the behavior, Avoid assumptions, Concentrate on impact, and Encourage self-reflection. By structuring my feedback in this way, I promote a constructive conversation that empowers team members to take ownership of their growth and development.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
LeadershipHere's how you can navigate resistance and defensiveness while receiving feedback.
-
Constructive FeedbackHow do you use feedback frequency and timing to motivate and empower others?
-
LeadershipHere's how you can effectively handle vague or unclear feedback.
-
Team FacilitationWhat do you do if feedback triggers defensiveness or personal offense?