What are the key factors to consider when comparing qualitative and quantitative demand forecasting methods?

Demand forecasting is the process of estimating the future demand for a product or service based on historical data, market trends, customer behavior, and other factors. It helps businesses plan their production, inventory, pricing, and marketing strategies to meet customer needs and maximize profits. However, demand forecasting is not a one-size-fits-all approach. There are different methods and techniques that can be used depending on the context, purpose, and data availability of the forecast. In this article, we will discuss the key factors to consider when comparing qualitative and quantitative demand forecasting methods, and how to choose the best one for your situation.

1 Qualitative methods

Qualitative demand forecasting methods rely on human judgment, intuition, and experience to make predictions based on subjective factors, such as opinions, preferences, expectations, and feelings. These methods are often used when there is little or no historical data available, or when the demand is influenced by unpredictable events, such as new product launches, social media trends, or political changes. Some examples of qualitative methods are surveys, focus groups, interviews, Delphi method, and scenario analysis. Qualitative methods are useful for capturing customer feedback, exploring new markets, and generating ideas, but they also have some limitations, such as bias, inconsistency, and lack of accuracy.

Add your perspective

Keith Holdsworth

Senior Supply Chain consultant specialised in delivering improvements in S&OP | IBP | Demand Planning | Supply Planning | Logistics | Training & Development | BCP | FMCG | Pharma | Chemicals
Report contribution
It can often be helpful to consider what instances of similar product launches, or similar situations, have occured in the past - and what happened then? Although you don't expect the product/situation to repeat itself exactly, these types of similar instances can be useful to give a scale of opportunity to the new product/situation you are trying to forecast. Forecasts also don't need to be exact numbers - but having a range from HIGH to LOW potential demand can be enough information to act upon sometimes at the outset, and then you can monitor the real sales to understand which trajectory you are following.

Like

2 Quantitative methods

Quantitative demand forecasting methods use mathematical models and statistical techniques to make predictions based on numerical data, such as sales, prices, income, population, and seasonality. These methods are often used when there is sufficient and reliable historical data available, and when the demand follows a regular pattern or trend. Some examples of quantitative methods are time series analysis, regression analysis, exponential smoothing, and moving averages. Quantitative methods are useful for identifying patterns, trends, and relationships, and providing precise and objective estimates, but they also have some challenges, such as data quality, complexity, and uncertainty.

Add your perspective

Adil Ilyas

Sales Engineer @ Total Parking Solutions | 8 Years Experience driving business growth through sales strategy and energy management solutions.
Report contribution
A simple yet effective way to use quantitative methods is to use a time series model. This model has many patterns that can be identified, such as levels, trends, and cycles. Some helpful time series models are the average method, moving average, weighted moving average, and exponential smoothing. Each of them have different methods and have their pros and cons.

Like

3 Factors to consider

When comparing qualitative and quantitative demand forecasting methods, there are several factors to consider. These include the purpose of the forecast, such as exploring new opportunities or optimizing existing operations; data availability and quality, such as the amount and reliability of data; and market dynamics and uncertainty, such as customer behavior and preferences. Depending on these factors, you may need a more subjective or objective method, a more simple or complex model, a more descriptive or predictive technique, a more intuitive or analytical method, a more qualitative or quantitative input, or a more deterministic or probabilistic output.

Add your perspective

4 How to choose the best method

Demand forecasting is an essential skill for any business striving to reach success in a competitive and ever-changing market. To select the best method for your needs, it is important to understand your forecasting problem, purpose, and scope. Assess the data availability and quality, as well as evaluate the market dynamics and uncertainty. Compare different methods and techniques based on their suitability, feasibility, and performance, while taking into account criteria such as simplicity, flexibility, validity, reliability, and transparency. Monitor and update your forecast regularly to track accuracy and error. Lastly, communicate your forecast results and implications to stakeholders.

Add your perspective

5 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

What are the key factors to consider when comparing qualitative and quantitative demand forecasting methods?

1

2

3

4

5

1 Qualitative methods

2 Quantitative methods

3 Factors to consider

4 How to choose the best method

5 Here’s what else to consider

Demand Forecasting

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Demand Forecasting

More relevant reading