How do you update your arguments?

1 Identify your premises

The first step to update your arguments is to identify your premises, or the statements that support your conclusion. Premises can be based on facts, opinions, values, or assumptions. You should be able to articulate your premises clearly and explicitly, and check if they are relevant, valid, and consistent. If you find any gaps, errors, or contradictions in your premises, you should revise them or look for alternative sources of support.

2 Seek feedback and criticism

The second step to update your arguments is to seek feedback and criticism from others, especially those who disagree with you or have different perspectives. Feedback and criticism can help you test your arguments, expose your blind spots, and discover new angles or insights. You should be open-minded and respectful when receiving feedback and criticism, and evaluate them based on their merits, not their sources. You should also be willing to admit your mistakes and change your mind if the evidence warrants it.

3 Compare your arguments

The third step to update your arguments is to compare your arguments with other arguments on the same issue or topic. Comparing your arguments can help you identify their strengths and weaknesses, as well as their similarities and differences. You should be able to recognize the assumptions, values, and implications of different arguments, and how they affect their conclusions. You should also be able to acknowledge the limitations and uncertainties of your own arguments, and avoid overgeneralizing or oversimplifying them.

4 Use logic and evidence

The fourth step to update your arguments is to use logic and evidence to support your claims and refute counterclaims. Logic and evidence can help you establish the validity and soundness of your arguments, as well as the credibility and reliability of your sources. You should be able to use logical reasoning, such as deduction, induction, and abduction, to construct coherent and consistent arguments. You should also be able to use relevant and sufficient evidence, such as data, statistics, examples, and testimonials, to back up your arguments and address potential objections.

5 Consider the context

The fifth step to update your arguments is to consider the context in which you are making or presenting your arguments. Context can influence the purpose, audience, tone, and format of your arguments, as well as the criteria and standards for evaluating them. You should be able to adapt your arguments to suit different contexts, such as academic, professional, or personal settings. You should also be aware of the ethical and social implications of your arguments, and how they might affect others or society.

6 Review and revise

The final step to update your arguments is to review and revise them periodically, especially when new information, evidence, or perspectives emerge. Reviewing and revising your arguments can help you keep them up to date, accurate, and relevant. You should be able to assess your arguments critically and objectively, and identify any areas for improvement or modification. You should also be able to communicate your arguments clearly and persuasively, and invite further feedback and criticism.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?