A healthcare team member resists constructive criticism. How do you manage them effectively?
When a healthcare team member resists constructive criticism, it can disrupt team dynamics and patient care. To manage this effectively, consider these strategies:
How do you handle resistance to feedback in your team?
A healthcare team member resists constructive criticism. How do you manage them effectively?
When a healthcare team member resists constructive criticism, it can disrupt team dynamics and patient care. To manage this effectively, consider these strategies:
How do you handle resistance to feedback in your team?
-
To manage a team member, who is resistant to constructive criticism, I will- 1.Initiate open and empathetic conversations to understand the root cause of their behavior and any underlying concerns. 2.Clearly communicate how constructive feedback, when embraced positively, can act as a powerful tool for professional development and significantly boost their career trajectory.
-
Managing resistance to constructive criticism requires empathy and clarity. Using the SBI Feedback Model (Situation-Behavior-Impact), I focus on describing specific instances and their outcomes without making it personal. During a team evaluation project, I encountered resistance but reframed feedback as a growth opportunity, allowing open dialogue to address concerns collaboratively. By fostering psychological safety and emphasizing shared goals, the team member became more receptive over time. For more insights, read "Radical Candor" by Kim Scott to master effective feedback delivery. Feedback is like a GPS—it guides, not criticizes. 🧭✨ Do follow for more insights like this! ♻️
-
When a healthcare team member resists constructive criticism, my approach is to stay calm, empathetic, and focused on collaboration. First, I would try to understand their perspective—maybe they’re feeling defensive, overwhelmed, or unsure about their performance. I believe it’s important to create a safe space for open dialogue, where they feel comfortable expressing concerns or challenges they’re facing. If they’re resistant, I’d give them time to process and follow up later to keep the conversation going. Ultimately, I’d try to align our goals for patient care and team success, so they understand the feedback is about achieving the best outcomes, not just correcting mistakes.
-
To manage a team member who resists constructive criticism, choose the right time and place, focus on behavior, provide specific examples, offer constructive feedback, actively listen, seek common ground, follow up, and implement these strategies to foster a culture of open communication and continuous improvement.
-
The way criticism is being delivered plays a vital role, even it is constructive. Our mind includes a diverse arena of perceptions built through our experiences and knowledge. The lens we choose will give the look of the world in similar fashion. Hence, understanding the lens of the team member is equally important before delivering any comments, because it would help in connecting with them. Once we connect, it would be easier to construct and convince the team. Our actions and the words we express also play key to build this connection. Not limited but for me some key actions - Connect, Compliment, Construct, Convince, Collaborate, Commit and Care would be important.
-
When a healthcare team member resists constructive criticism, fostering a growth mindset is key to effective management. Create a supportive culture where feedback is framed as an opportunity for learning and improvement, not as a personal critique. Use specific examples to explain the behavior and its impact, helping them see feedback as a path to growth. Encourage open dialogue to understand their perspective and collaboratively develop actionable solutions. By reinforcing the idea that skills and behaviors can improve with effort and guidance, you promote resilience and adaptability, benefiting both the individual and the team.
-
When a healthcare team member resists constructive criticism, I focus on fostering a growth-oriented and collaborative approach: 1. Create a supportive environment: I emphasize that feedback is intended to help improve performance and benefit the entire team, making it less personal and more constructive. 2. Provide specific examples: I use clear, concrete examples to explain the behavior and its impact, ensuring the feedback is understood in context. 3. Encourage open dialogue: I invite the team member to share their perspective, addressing any concerns and working together to develop actionable solutions.
-
Build trust and rapport with the team member. Focus on specific behaviors, not personal attacks. Frame criticism as constructive feedback for growth. Encourage active listening and dialogue. Provide support and resources for skill development. Address underlying concerns or anxieties. Set clear expectations and consequences for persistent resistance. Document all interactions for future reference.
-
A resistant team member often has something else going on. Because I don't know where their thoughts are coming from, I begin with, "What would be most helpful for you to talk about today?" Silence is okay. Whatever they bring up will be relevant. Sometimes people are not ready. Perhaps reexploring later will help. They may not have insight yet. Be patient. Develop trust. Occasionally, I have people who do not open. I wish them the best and hope that they will get insight somewhere. Sometimes a discussion with someone else will help them.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Healthcare ManagementHere's how you can effectively follow up on feedback with your healthcare team.
-
HealthcareWhat do you do if a healthcare professional needs constructive feedback?
-
Working with PhysiciansYou’re working with physicians and you don’t agree with their feedback. What’s the best way to handle it?
-
Healthcare ManagementHere's how you can handle negative feedback from your team members as a healthcare manager.